Tuesday, October 6, 2009

144 - As if my own hand clasped the whip


Excerpt from the proceedings of the Chevengani Mental State Assessment Committee,
atakina 9, Y. 1556

Da: With great regret, I propose that we request of the Servant of Michalere that he resign from the Committee... I would even go so far as to say that the Servant of Michalere has made use of his position on the Committee to further his aim of removing Chevenga by damaging his reputation—which is an abuse of his position on the Committee.

…

Li: Thank you for your fairness, president Lanai. That was quite the damning presentation, Darosera, but I’ll contend myself that it is only so on the surface, and answer your accusations point for point…

…

La: Thank you, Darosera, for your presentation, and Linasika, for your defense. That we request of the Servant of Michalere to resign from the Committee due to a conflict of interest of intent, discussion from other members: I recognize the Servant of Terera South.

Ku: Thank you. Now, as you all know, the citizens I represent are very convenient to me here, and so I am never really away from them, as are those of you from more distant counties. Thus I hear from them every day. Now I have had more than one person say to me in the last few days, “I thought the Committee was convened to study Chevenga’s mental state; why are you out to destroy him?”

Each time I have said it is not so, of course, but then asked, “How did you come to think that?” And each time I’ve been told “Linasika said,” or been shown a quote from the Servant of Michalere. Each time I say, “That is his view; he does not speak for the entire Committee.” And often I hear, “He doesn’t? But it sounds that way.”

Now I don’t know whether it’s by implying that he speaks for the Committee, or simply the number of times that he has spoken to writers about what we do here, while the rest of us have generally not done so at all, Linasika is giving this impression enough that people are getting it. I don’t think this is proper. Our mandate is to investigate and then present the people of Yeola-e with a complete report at the end of that investigation, all properly written, and signed by all of us as members. It isn’t to spread selected bits of our proceedings to the public before we’ve even formed conclusions, let alone finished the report. The Servant of Michalere’s doing that has made me for one feel ill-at-ease. I have to share the opinion that it has been done specifically to harm Chevenga’s good name and standing, and agree that this is not something any of us should be doing.

La: I recognize the Servant of Kaholil.

Cha: Thank you, sib president. The Committee resolved at the outset, though I can’t recall the precise wording, to treat Chevenga with sympathy rather than judgment in our dealings with him. Now Linasika is speaking ad hoc to the writers, of course, so we can’t say his efforts in that respect are Committee dealings, but when we question, and we vote, those most certainly are Committee dealings. I must concur with Darosera that now and then, during questioning sessions—especially the one under truth-drug—the Servant of Michalere has taken quite the opposite approach, in breach of that resolution. That session was in fact precipitated by repeated accusations of dishonesty on Chevenga’s part, and repeated threats to him of truth-drugging, even though we had voted not to use it, from Linasika. We all know that Chevenga did not consent to it so much as insist on it, out of what I consider a quite understandable anger. It’s a stain on the good name of this Committee, as far as I’m concerned, that he has been treated so poorly by us, even though we’d committed ourselves—as well as being required, by simple courtesy—to treat him well, that he felt impelled to do this. I have said little about it, but I’ve been increasingly concerned over time about how Linasika’s Chevenga-grudge has been made manifest here, inappropriately.

I draw my fellow-members’ attention to the voting record also. I haven’t gone through the record to do a count, but I doubt I am the only one who has noticed how many times our vote-counts have been six chalks and one charcoal, with Linasika dissenting on anything favourable to Chevenga, no matter how minor. For example, the times in which he’s requested of us that we call in his healer with him—which is invariably helpful to our investigation, since Surya so frequently and ably clarifies matters—Linasika votes against, as if Chevenga having his healer there is somehow too easy on him. Just now, at the start of today, he requested that we schedule any questionings of him around the Games, as he’s taking part—not an unreasonable request, since we’re past the phase of questioning him intensely. But Linasika voted charcoal, and cast aspersions on Chevenga’s motives for taking part in the Games by way of explanation. To me these things seem like no more than unthinking attempts to make his life more difficult in any way possible, and they are not appropriate to the proceedings of a Committee of the Assembly of Yeola-e. That’s all for now, thank you.

La: I recognize the Servant of Tassumai.

I: I think that the Servant of Thara-e-Kalanera has made many good points, and I also think the Servant of Michalere has answered them well. I agree with the latter that it is our duty as public servants to be vigilant in regard to wrongdoing by our fellow public servants, but I tend to agree also with the former that the latter has been somewhat excessive in his vigilance.

However I think that Linasika has been a very valuable member of our Committee, and his contribution would be sorely missed. It’s as Darosera said in her motion; his presence has brought a suitable balance in our measure of a person who is so charismatic, and has become so dear to the hearts of Yeolis, that he has the usename “Beloved,” so that it’s very difficult, I think, for any citizen of this nation to hold an unemotional view of him at all. I think that is very valuable and our work as a Committee would suffer without it. Accordingly, I would vote charcoal to the proposal, with the intention of instead proposing that we formally censure the Servant of Michalere for certain of the actions he has taken, to be agreed upon, and abjure him not to do the like for the duration of the mandate of this Committee. Thank you.

La: I recognize the Servant of Thara-e-Tinanga-e.

O: Thank you, president Lanai. I would like to say that, while I rarely meet constituents of mine in the streets when I am here, unlike Kusiya, I have heard similar to what he has from citizens, at least I presume they are citizens, of Terera and Vae Arahi.

As you might recall, I voted chalk for truth-drugging Chevenga; my thought was that it might perhaps clear the air and open the way for some measure of reconciliation between the Servant of Michalere and the semanakraseye. Since he was flogged, I’ve been asked by many people—upwards of thirty—which way I voted, and berated by the majority of them for it, since it led to what, in their view, was a harsh punishment unjustly inflicted. And I have to say that had I known what the ultimate result would be, I would never have voted as I did. There is no vote I have ever taken in my time as a Servant that I have regretted more. I feel as if my own hand clasped the whip, in part.

I should add that I have yet to hear any Yeoli thank me for that vote, or say that they are glad Chevenga was flogged because he was deserving of it and Yeola-e will be better for it, or that he ought to be impeached. The closest I’ve heard to a favourable reaction is words along the lines of, ‘Maybe it was good in the sense that it will slake the thirst of the Chevenga-haters and they’ll lay off him.’

Now I admit that this is his place of origin and he is more closely known and deeply loved here than anywhere else in Yeola-e, but if there’s a such unanimity of feeling here, that feeling must surely be held by a sizable majority in the rest of the country. I expect that we will all receive many letters in the next half-moon.

La: Pardon me for interceding, Omonae, but I would like to survey, by a show of hands, the full Committee, for the record. To each of you, have you heard similar sentiments expressed informally—or formally, for that matter—and in similar proportions, as Kusiya and Omonae have, since Chevenga’s flogging? I see four chalks and two charcoals. Five chalks if I may be counted. I ask the Servant of Tassumai, who answered charcoal, in what proportion have you heard favourable and unfavourable reactions to what we’ve done in relation to the charges and sentence?

I: I would estimate I’ve heard about three in four unfavourable, and the three are passionate, whereas the one is more… what I would describe as dutiful.

La: Servant of Michalere, the second chalk vote?

L: I have heard about half and half. All passionate, but the unfavourable ones extremely passionate. I’ve been spat at on the street. I’ve been told that if Chevenga commits suicide it will be my fault, and I’ve even been accused of wanting him dead.

La: Thank you, all; Omonae, please continue.

O: Well, I would also like to recount a bit of conversation I overheard between two writers, one a Yeoli and one an Arkan, while they were attending an Assembly session yesterday. They had also both attended the flogging. I heard the Arkan say words to this effect: “I don’t understand what you Yeolis have against Chevenga. You’re harder on him than we are, and he saved you all, while he conquered our empire and sacked our capital. I’m not sure that being rewarded this sort of way for everything he’s done wouldn’t make me want to jump off a cliff, too, if I were him.” Now it’s only an opinion, of course, and it’s from a foreigner, who doesn’t understand our culture; but still I think, frankly, it’s telling. I think—

I: Forgive me for interceding, but I’m curious to know how the Yeoli answered, if you heard.

O: I did, and he answered, and I ask the Committee to excuse me for using the language he did, “If I were him, I’d resign in disgust and tell us all to eat shit. I think he doesn’t only because he knows that Linasika and his ilk are few and everyone reasonable is with him.”

Li: Quaint language.

O: Forgive me, Linasika, I admit I’ve toned down how he characterized you, somewhat.

La: Continue please, Omonae.

O: Thank you. I think, with all due respect to the Servant of Michalere, that his actions are a clear sign that, where it concerns Chevenga, he has allowed emotion to outstrip reason, and I wonder at this point whether he is capable of reversing that, given how publicly he has committed himself to his position. Thank you.

La: I recognize the Servant of Tinga-e-Pekola.

Mi: Thank you, president. I essentially have my mind made up on this, and I get the impression that everyone else does, too, and so I have little to say. But I’d like to note that I have observed on many occasions that the Servant of Michalere has been so manifestly passionate in his anti-Chevenga stance during our deliberations that it’s disrupted our process to some degree, with interruptions, exclamations that were out of order, outbursts that have raised tensions and disturbed the peace among us, and in short made it more difficult for all of us. If other members of the Committee request it I will go through the record and make a count of instances, but we’ve all been witness to them so I hope that isn’t necessary. That is all. Thank you.

La: Now all have spoken once, and I know some are hungering very much to answer each other’s points, but I think continuation best go to a vote. That we call the debate and vote on the motion, all chalk, all charcoal, I see four chalks and three charcoals, carried by a majority, thank you. That we respectfully request of the Servant of Michalere to resign from the Committee due to a conflict of interest in intent, with the Servant himself recused from the vote, I see four chalks, one charcoal and one abstention, carried by a majority, thank you. Now it falls to the Servant of Michalere to accede to or deny our request.

Li: I wouldn’t dream of denying it, sib gentlefolk. I hereby resign my position on the Chevengani Mental State Assessment Committee, effective immediately. May Yeola-e be the better for it.



--

Read More......

Monday, October 5, 2009

143 - All it needs is practice

“No, you were not imagining it,” said Surya. “I did say ‘Welcome.’ ”

One balm for whip-welts I hadn’t had in the war-camp in my teens: a hot tub. I relished it now. Beside me sat Kasai, also immersed up to his chin; I’d invited him up, to let him know he was forgiven. “I’ll soak my back and you soak your arm, together,” I’d said.

“My soul,” I asked Surya. “What did it look like?”

“A bright point of white light with your eyes.”

“Really?”

“Well, not exactly, but that’s the simplest way to put it. Try this: you had no face, but I could tell when you were smiling.” To my surprise, I found I actually knew what he meant.

“You mean your soul was outside your body?” Kasai said. “I thought that only happened when you—I mean, when a person—dies.”

“Anyone can learn how to do it,” said Surya. “It just takes practice. The main trick is to get over the fear. I do a little soul-traveling every night.”

“So you didn’t feel the pain?” Kasai’s eyes looked at me full of hope.

“Oh, I wouldn’t say that.” The thought that was crossing my mind was of legality; perhaps I’d had too much law on the brain lately. Nowhere in Yeoli law does it state that the soul of a person being duly punished with a flogging is prohibited from leaving his body, but as the purpose of the sentence is atonement by pain, he’s implicitly required to feel it. “I felt it, but… it’s hard to describe. Let’s just say, it made it more bearable.” Of course if it got back to the Assembly, they might consider my soul leaving my body a sign that the flogging had been appropriately severe.

“So anyone can learn just to do it by will, no need to be suffering?” I asked Surya. “Maybe I already can.”

“Only one way to find out,” said Surya.

I closed my eyes, and tried. Nothing happened. “I hope I don’t have to learn this by gradually decreasing the amount of suffering to nothing,” I said. “That would be a lot of suffering.”

Surya cast an aura-seeing glance over me, and said, “Ask yourself about the fear.”

Yes, it was there. And the feeling that I could do it that I’d had while I was being flogged was not. There is nothing to fear, I told myself. No harm came to me last time. I’ve done it in front of Surya and Kasai both before. I fixed my eyes on a crack between two tiles on the opposite side of the tub, slowed and deepened my breathing, made my muscles relax all over. Seeing I was putting myself into trance, neither of them said anything. Everything but the crack faded from my vision; time slowed; then the feeling came again, that I could do it, though it was not so strong. I closed my eyes, and I was about an arm’s-length above and behind my own head, seeing the three of us from behind. Surya turned his head to look right up at me, and smiled. I snapped back into myself with a bit of a yelp.

“All it needs is practice,” he said.

†

I had healer’s orders, of course, to live an easy life for the next few days. I mostly lazed around the Hearthstone Independent, writing the odd letter. There were no sessions with Surya, who busied himself overseeing the removal of walls in his chambers in the Independent, then helping Anchera, Janinara-e and their children move in. The four-to-be and their young were all hitting it off well enough, it seemed to me, when they invited my four and young for dinner on the second night.

The only thing I did every day, such as it was, was practice soul-traveling. I always did it wearing the brass chain, which somehow seemed to make it easier. Surya gave me a little more advice: not to go into it fearful, and not be surprised or frightened by anything I did see. The other world is full of creatures that we cannot see in this one, and not all of them are kindly.

When I started training again, Surya had me try it wearing the brass chain, which Azaila approved of. Hardest was sparring with it on. I had to keep reminding myself, ‘This is just for training; I’d never do it in a real fight.’ Then, ‘I’m planning never to be in a real fight again anyway.’ Then he had me wear it for whole days, now and then. It was all disorienting enough to be transformative, I assumed.

I did go before the Committee a couple of times. The two Servants assigned to read my autobiographical scribblings had finished, and the others had read the parts they’d excerpted, and they wanted clarifications on this and that, nothing too harrowing.

Chosaiya was right—I sometimes wondered whether she’d ever been wrong in her life—that the flogging would bring a backlash, so to speak. The press pages got many letters decrying the unfairness of it from all over the country, as did the Servants of Assembly. I paid little attention; my back healed, and I wondered vaguely when Surya and I would get around to settling the matter of whether I truly wanted to be semanakraseye or not.

By now, the shepherds had brought the sheep down from the high heights to the mid-heights, the corn was all in, and the Circle School Annual Games were approaching.

The Games, in case you don’t know, are the final step in selecting the three people who will be admitted into the Circle School, which is now held to be the best academy of general-craft in the world, each year. Any Yeoli may try to enter, and the school is funded entire by the public purse, so even a person who is dirt-poor can graduate.

To get in, you first have to write a lengthy examination; then you have to face eight other candidates in one-day war-games around the country. The twenty-four who do best compete in the Annual Games, with an army of twenty-thousand split between them. We’ve made a festival out of it, of course; for a half-moon every fall, Terera and Vae Arahi both are crawling with warriors, and the tavern-keepers and vintners all make up any losses they might have suffered in the rest of the year. All the generals in Yeola-e, also, unless they’re on duty somewhere, use the Games as an excuse to get together, enthrall the bright-eyed up-and-comers, drunkenly second-guess each other’s old battles, and try to clobber each other on the sand-table, laesha-board, and so forth.

I am going to reveal a sordid secret of Yeoli military history, here, since confession seems to be the turn my life has taken. As I wrote before, once I had my wristlets, I formed the ambition to beat out Naishana Krai, who entered the School at sixteen and graduated at twenty, to be the youngest Circle School student, and graduate, ever. But, aside from falling short on the examination at thirteen, and the preliminary games at fourteen, I was fighting the Lakans for two years after that. I made it into the School at seventeen, and became demarch when I was about two-thirds of the way through. What is not so well known is I was still missing the naval aspect of the course—I was trying to fit in some time in Selina to practice commanding ship-battles—when I went to Arko, which, of course, finished my chances to do anything but fight and work for six years.

When I got back to Yeola-e and joined the army in Ossotyeya, with the whole nation’s life-and-death hopes pinned on me, Nainara Shae-Miya, the dean, came to my tent to give me the Circle School’s news. Like everyone else, they had suffered and lost at the hands of Arko, about a third of the teachers and students killed in action before Artira ordered the rest to cease to preserve themselves. They’d split up then, those from the south mostly joining Renaina Chaer, those from the north staying with Hurai, and some from the plains joining the resistance there, allowed to study and consult on command councils, but not fight. “So often,” Nainara said, “the lesson was, what did we do wrong, and they do right?” Nine times out of ten, I noticed, the meat of the lesson was the work of Triadas Teleken, one thing that urged me toward assassinating him.

“So,” Nainara said to me, “we are at your service, the teachers to consult, the students to learn.”

“To learn?” I said. “Three quarters of them must be as qualified as I. Here I am, appointing myself First General First, and I haven’t even graduated.”

She seemed to slightly flinch on the word graduated, and flashed a glance over her shoulder almost involuntarily. “You know, Fourth Chevenga, sometimes honesty and openness just do not suit,” she said, her voice a little lower. “None of us mentioned this to anyone, in fact we all swore silence. You must agree this is for the best.”

“Well, I wasn’t about to proclaim it. I just don’t have the pin, if anyone looks closely.”

“Probably no one will, just as no one seems to want to ask us. We were thinking of giving it to you honourarily, on the assumption you will finish later.”

I had thought of this, but was too shy to bring it up myself. “If you think it best,” I said. “My honour as a warrior opposes it... but Yeola-e can’t afford me to have anything but a demarch’s honour now.”

“It’s only sea-borne strategy and tactics you’re missing,” she said. “We never did get you to Selina. Is it true you fought against Arkan quinqueremes on Haiu Menshir? I’ve heard the story, but it seems so implausible on so many counts, not the least that the Arkans would attack Haiu Menshir in the first place.”

“Utterly implausible,” I said, “but true—they did. What else in what you heard was implausible?”

“That you defeated them with only a handful of warriors and a herd of sailors, taking no losses at all. Even though you were still considered to be, em...”

“Insane. Well, it was more than a handful: I had my guard, who were twenty, mostly elite, and seventy Srian archers. I hid the green ribbon under my wristlet. Aside from that, it is true.”

Nainara pulled a notebook and pen out of her satchel. “This sounds like an interesting study. Will you tell me the whole story, from the beginning of anything that was relevant to it, leaving out no detail? No, wait—let me send for the students.”

I recounted it for them, and they drank it in like the first swallows of water in a desert, as all Yeolis did then, it being their first taste of victory against Arko.

“Here is what we will do,” said Nainara, when she and I were alone again. She took off her own Circle School pin, awarded her when my father was a baby, and held it out to me. “People are even less likely to ask me than you. Borrow it until you receive your own. No protests, semanakraseye: semana kra.”

I didn’t graduate until four years later, when I’d been impeached and therefore had time to visit Selina. I did it almost more for the principle of the matter than anything else, so I could graduate before I died.

So there is the shameful truth: the freeing of Yeola-e and conquest of Arko was led by one whose Circle School education was incomplete, and was in fact fraudulently wearing the dean’s pin. I hope Linasika Aramichiya doesn’t find a way to have me charged after he reads this.



--

Read More......

Friday, October 2, 2009

142 - Justice was done


Two steps away from her, I turned back. “As if I don’t know what I will decide,” I said. “Yes.”

†

The next morning, we were all actors on a stage. Tresaha argued sternly to the judges that they should impeach and bar me from reinstatement for the rest of my life, and Chosaiya argued passionately that I deserved censure only. Then the judges stepped in, asking the advocates both to moderate their positions, patiently talking them into grudging concessions. “We will consider sparing you from impeachment only if you are willing to undertake the most severe atonement,” the Arch-Arbiter said to me, very gravely.

For my part, when they asked me if I’d accept flogging to falling, I brought the last time to mind, giving myself another taste of bile and sickness, to make sure I had the right look on my face. I guess I was being myself in a carefully calculated way. The ironies lived by people of the law are exceeded only by those of politicians.

They found a whip-wielder in the palace staff, a man in his early twenties who’d moved to Terera only three moons or so before, and trained at one of the schools there, and so had never met me. We set it for the next afternoon, to give people time to hear. “I do need your help with the apology,” I said to Chosaiya. “How do I say I am sorry when I’ve said I don’t regret?” As always, she was unhesitating with insight.

I remember the fall wind blowing crisp off the lake, which I’d kiss again if I were re-approved. The flogging-post and chairs for the Arch-Arbitrate and several other officials were set up on a dais. The mood of the crowd had a solemnity not unlike what it is for the Kiss of the Lake, but with more sympathy for me. I heard more than one person yell things like, “This is not being done in my name!” and “Chevenga, you’re being punished for saving us!” Of course it’s always easiest to win the trial of the street and the dinner-table in your hometown. Though Chosaiya need not be here, she was anyway. Maybe she wanted to see the end of a story she had done so much to author. Krero made sure Kaninjer and Surya were right at the edge of the dais.

I raised my arms for quiet. “My people, whom I love,” I said, and heard relayed back through them, “I know that many of you feel that it’s injustice more than justice being done here, that I am being punished where I should be rewarded. From my heart, I thank you for your mercy and your kindness. I know many of you are also thinking, what is the point of court-ordered apologies, for how can an expression of regret that a person is forced to make be sincere and worth anything? So say it and get it over with, Chevenga, you’re thinking, since we know to ignore it anyway.” They laughed all the harder for not having expected any laughs.

“But the fact is that I did break the law. Even if it was to better serve the spirit of the law, I broke the letter, and the letter is the law no less than the spirit, and has its place just as the spirit does. I have never denied to myself that I broke it, and having been charged, I won’t deny it to anyone else. But by denying it entirely before that, I was doing harm. I’m not well-known for agreeing with Linasika Aramichiya”—that got another laugh—“but one thing he said stuck in my mind. ‘When one person guards a secret, everyone else is unarmed with truth, and thus defenseless.’ He said that he had always had a feeling about me that I was hiding something, and that he was not alone in this, and in truth I can’t imagine he could have been alone in it—since he, and everyone else who felt it too, was right. I was indeed keeping a secret, and those who sensed it could not know what to do, unarmed with truth as they were.

“That is the nature of the harm I did, and it is indeed harm to the entire people of Yeola-e. And while I can never regret making use of my position as I did in the Arkan war, I do regret the price that Yeola-e paid for it, in absence of truth, and a violation, unknown to them, of what is sacred. For that I am, from my heart, truly and deeply sorry. To the punishment decreed by the Arch-Arbitrate, I submit myself.”

I undid the first clasp of my shirt, and the whip-wielder came up next to me. “Semanakraseye,” he said shyly, “I thought I should not do this to you without at least introducing myself.” His name was Kasai Tenora, he was from Porokaralinga, he’d squired in the Arkan war and now worked in Assembly Palace as a runner. “It will come from my arm,” he said. “Never from my heart.” I clasped his hand, and said, “Go warm up that arm then; even if it doesn’t seem so, the harder you hit, the easier it is for me. And don’t worry; I won’t take it personally for an instant.” As he warmed his arm, I finished stripping.

He had rope ready to bind my wrists to the post, but I signed charcoal, braced myself against it with one hand and set my teeth. There was a buzz of acclaim from the crowd, and then they began shouting their strength-blessings and encouragements.

The last time had been when I was fifteen; fourteen years, and a thousand more severe agonies, ago. I was just thinking this will be nothing when I heard the whistling hiss, and the first one landed. Kyash, I thought, I’d swear it didn’t hurt so much before. The second one confirmed it. He was doing it hard as I’d advised, but no harder than Hurai’s whip-wielder or Elera Shae-Tyeba had. Have I got out of practice? I took in a deep breath, and couldn’t help but think breathe in acceptance again, as the third stroke came. Or is it… age? I’d turn twenty-nine in a half-moon or so. I realized, even as I heard the whistling of the fourth stroke coming, that this was the first time in my life I’d ever thought I might be feeling the effects of age.

At least Kasai’s strokes were dead even, both in the time between them and their force, which is easier, because you learn what to expect, and so you’re not so afraid of the next. I remembered how Elera had made no two the same, a flogging from the deepest pits of Arkan Hayel.

After the fifth, I gave myself entirely to the internal struggle that is the essence of being flogged: to feel the pain without either fleeing from it physically or expressing it. Later I’d take up the struggle that is the essence of being flogged to falling: first, against the temptation to fake it and fall before you are truly unconscious so as to make it stop, and second, against unconsciousness itself—the hardest one, since the body knows unconsciousness is relief, and so it’s relief itself you are fighting. Whether I was feeling it more or not, I was feeling it differently; it seemed to me that the Arkan torture had left me stronger in some ways and weaker in others.

But some things are always the same, so I knew how it would go. If your mind is a house in a city that is being sacked, each whip-stroke is another torch thrown into it. From their small flames uniting, the conflagration grows slowly, its tendrils creeping upwards and throughout, until there is only flame in the shape of a house, or pain in the shape of a mind. When the posts and beams are eaten away enough, it all comes crashing down and apart; then, of course, is when you open your eyes bewildered, find yourself looking at concerned faces with sky between them, and realize it’s over.

So I set off down this path, making myself steel all over so I would not step off it until the pain dissolved my will. I suddenly understood what was harder; as a youth I’d been more ruled by habit and training, more lock-step. In my old age, my mind had become more free. It was the ninth or tenth stroke and I was just thinking I’m not going to last as long, when I realized an astonishing thing.

Several times in Arko, being tortured, I’d been split asunder, my soul driven out of my body, so I’d find myself looking at myself from a distance, from above or a little behind. Now, even though this pain was not nearly as bad as that, being much less laced with terror, I suddenly knew, with complete certainty, that I could do it again right now, but by will, perfectly freely. I need only close my eyes.

I stood stunned, as the next stroke came—late, as Kasai had for some reason faltered—and wondered what had made this possible. My healing? Becoming senahera? The thing that had happened in the woods? All of it? I decided to try it, but fear made me hesitate; the next whip-stroke searing across my back fueled my courage. I closed my eyes, and I was looking down at myself, naked with one hand on the pole, my hair in the overgrown warrior-cut stringy with sweat, and the whip-welts scarlet across my back.

It’s hard to put into words. I still fully felt the pain, or at least was fully aware of it; it just didn’t matter. I found I could control where my soul flew, like a bird, though I didn’t want to fly too far. Now I saw why Kasai was having trouble; he was blinded by tears welling up too fast to blink away. The yells of the crowd I had lost while I’d been incarnate, pain boiling them away; now I heard them clearly again, each one sharp and distinct, mostly “Strength!” and “We love you!” and my name. Someone handed him a hand-towel, and he managed to get back into his rhythm by keeping it pressed against his eyes between strokes.

It was the same as always, feeling my mind weaken from solid to a little mad to struggling for control to reeling to going out like a candle; except that I watched from afar, undisturbed, attaching no meaning to it. I saw and felt myself stagger forward; I distantly directed myself to grab the post with both hands, and ask myself where the insides of my cheeks, my lips and my tongue were in relation to my teeth; you can bite yourself without knowing it. Krero and Kyirya stepped close now, ready to catch me. The next stroke put me on my knees, and Kasai stopped. Something told me to fly to where I could look at my own face. Though it was pouring sweat, there was no grimace on it at all, not even strain around the closed eyes; it was impassive like a monk’s in meditation. I realized why: I’m not inside. I’m out here. I couldn’t wait to tell Surya this—no. He can see it. I flew up a man-height or so and looked; sure enough, he was gazing not at my body, but right at me, seeing me as clearly as if we’d locked eyes. A smile pulled at his lips. I called to him. I’m in your world! Clear as if he’d spoken aloud, I heard him answer, Welcome.

There was something else I had to do, though; I gave the order, and watched myself struggle to haul myself, half-conscious and quivering all over, back up to standing. I wrapped my arms hard around the post; I was almost done, but if I put enough will into them, I knew, it would take two or three more strokes. The crowd’s applause faded fast to silence. The next one made me know nothing but my arms; then Kasai, not wanting to do more than one more, took the whip-handle in both hands, let out a war-cry full of anguish and gave it everything he had. I thrashed once, all the way out to my fingers and toes, and went boneless; Krero and Kyirya caught me under the arms and head, laid me gently face-down on the dais, then gave the crowd a clear view to let them be witness, and it was over.

I took my time. There was no sense at all that it was anything but entirely my choice; as soon as I opened my eyes, I’d be back in. I had no way of knowing whether I had bitten myself because I could feel nothing; why, I thought, when we use the bite-strap for other painful things, don’t we use it for this? I’d suggest it to the court, I decided, and the generals; if they agreed it would become the custom. I remember aligning my soul behind my eyes and at the right angle. I can’t say how strange it was. Then I was looking at the wood-grain of the dais and my own wrist, and feeling instant nausea and my skin go icy except on my back, where it was on fire. The pain mattered again.

The medicines that Kaninjer dropped on my tongue helped. “I have to get up,” I whispered. “By myself. No matter how long it takes. Don’t help me.” Another barbaric Yeoli thing, I could hear him think. I did it slowly, breathing deeply and asking myself many questions, while the crowd shouted their exhortations; if you don’t pay careful attention to the state of your head at each step of the way, you can easily keel over again, and then the friends and the healer won’t give you another chance. Finally I straightened up, kissed Kasai’s hand as tradition requires, and faced the crowd with my hands crossed on my heart, to their roar, which was anger as much as admiration. With Krero following close beside me, I went to the judges and we signed off all the papers. Justice was done.



--

Read More......

Thursday, October 1, 2009

141 - I did not know my own heart


Darosera’s questions, of course, took my side. So it went for the rest of the day: a debate in the guise of a questioning, back and forth between those who wanted to forgive and re-approve me and those who wanted to retire me, augmented by the few who wanted to fling me off a cliff. In answering, I hammered on the spirit versus the letter, the way the war had turned out, and my other best points; in asking, they took me to task on my weakest, including having told others, including three Arkans (Kallijas, Skorsas and Idiesas) before telling Assembly. Chosaiya’s signs were invaluable several more times.

It’s impossible, in truth, to discern well from how many speak which way the whole will vote—the majority remains silent, and gives no sign—but it’s also impossible not to try anyway. I had a feeling all but a few were with me, on this; whether they’d still think I was capable of being semanakraseye after they read the Committee’s report was another question entirely.

During the mid-afternoon rest break, Chosaiya slipped away somewhere. When we adjourned for the day, she took me into a corner of the courtyard again. I still remember the sun on the flagstones, dappled with the shade of a rowan tree, and the fast-cooling autumn air.

“We almost have it,” she said. “I met with Tresaha and the Arch-Arbiter in the break. You said you’d take a flogging to stay semanakraseye. What if it were to falling?”

I signed chalk, and felt a sudden streak of nausea up my centre and tang of bile on my tongue. I hadn’t known my body so remembered.

“Are you sure, Chevenga? You know what it means.”

“Yes, I am sure.” I signed chalk again, harder, for emphasis. Sweat broke out cold all over the skin of my back, and my mouth was suddenly parched. I know what it means. We try to master these things, we try to be so strong that the pain of the past can no longer touch us, but it lingers in the cells, and they are involuntary. Of course it showed on my face; she patted my shoulder in a motherly way.

“Understand, though, it’s just the Arch-Arbitrate I’m dealing with now, not Assembly,” she said, in a tone like a healer takes when telling you that the treatment will cause some pain. “No judicial impeachment doesn’t mean no Assembly impeachment, or, more exactly, yes to re-approval. You could be flogged to falling and still have it taken away from you, especially if the Committee reports unfavourably.

“I think, though, that Assembly is more likely to re-approve you with the more severe punishment. As I said before: it’s atonement, cleansing, an acknowledgment of the seriousness of what you did and acceptance of an accordingly serious punishment.” Breathe in acceptance, I thought. It helped, actually. “The people who fear you are out in the open, now; Linasika gave them their voice. The greater and freer submission you are willing to show them, the more their fear will be eased.”

I swallowed the words I wanted to rail, They have nothing to fear, why do they fear, what have I ever done to earn fear, where does all this mad hate come from?, and just signed chalk again. People are people, that was all.

“Flogging to falling, public apology and no judicial impeachment—agree to that, Chevenga, and we’re done. It’ll be the last arguments and the open negotiation first thing in the morning, and we’ll have a decision by midday tomorrow.”

It was not the plausible best case, but it was far from the worst. I reminded myself, the trial of the street and the dinner-table. “When would I do the apology, and get flogged?”

“You could do the apology right then. After the midday break, if you want my help with it. Or you could take more time to prepare it; I wouldn’t suggest longer than seven days, though. Your choice.” It seemed odd to have any choices here. “The flogging… the interesting thing there will be finding someone who’s willing to do it. Every warrior around here knows you, true? Maybe I’ll ask Linasika if someone in his shadowy horde of Chevenga-fearers has a good whip-arm.” I let out a snort of laughter, in spite of myself.

“Same thing,” she said. “You don’t want to put it off by your choice for longer than seven days. The trial of the street—”

“And the dinner-table,” we said in unison.

“It might have the greatest effect to do both at once, actually, in the place where the largest crowd can witness,” she said thoughtfully. “Because there will be a backlash, too. A great many people feel that it’s a bitter injustice that you were charged at all, and they’ll be even angrier and louder about it seeing you flogged. You can imagine the letters they will write to their Servants. That is… if you’re willing to bear the humiliation.”

“Terera Square,” I said, my voice weaker than I’d intended.

I was about to give my consent when a thought stopped me. It was not three moons and a half since I’d torn off the seals and the signet, stopped only from quitting by Kall braining me, and then the true argument that there’d be bloodshed in Arko if I did. Which no longer applied. Surya and I had deferred the question, and not yet taken it up again.

I had been absolutely certain that I no longer wanted to be semanakraseye then; and yet more recently, the moment I’d been deemed competent again, I’d gone at a fair run to Assembly to be ceremonially reinstated. Had the urge to quit come purely from exhaustion? Or the urge to stay, purely from habit? I realized, I did not know my own heart.

“You’re not sure,” Chosaiya said gently, her hand on my shoulder again, like that of the most confident of mothers. “You want to sleep on it? Let me know early enough tomorrow morning and it might still be over midday tomorrow.” I signed chalk.



--

Read More......

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

140 - Half a leap across an abyss


17th of the Terera Pages – e92 56

Chevenga ~ eagle’s claws ~ open eyes, Shae-Shaila, continued

We would not fault anyone, given such an augury, for curling up or keeling over in the middle of it, for becoming too overwhelmed with emotion to ask further questions, for running panicked for help to anyone and everyone afterwards, for throwing the whole thing to Assembly for a decision. We would particularly not fault a nineteen-year-old man less than a month away from taking on the most responsible position in the land.

But Chevenga did none of these things. In the face of the most awful prognostications imaginable both for himself personally and everyone he holds dear, he conducted the augury all through with care and skill, then followed its prescription for the best result with steely nerve, not letting slip what he’d learned, and heading to Arko despite knowing full well that terrible suffering awaited him there.

Yes, it seemed the only alternative to a death even more premature than the one he was already expecting; but we would not entirely fault anyone in his position, either, for losing his nerve on the way there and fleeing home in the unreasoning hope of finding some mythical fourth fork that escaped the bitterest of choices—or even elsewhere, so as to keep his own skin intact. Even accepting one of the first two forks might have been easier, allowing him death—the ultimate evasion of responsibility—of a kind that would have left him remembered as a hero. A person of lesser spirit would have welcomed that.

During the rest-breaks at the trial after Chevenga revealed the reading, and again after it was over, he was enveloped by Servants and watchers from the gallery, gathering to embrace him and otherwise express gratitude and admiration. It was a while before he could speak to the assembled writers, and a while again before I could draw him out alone.

†

“Semana kra. It would be best for Yeola-e and so it was what I had to do, whatever it led to.” Chevenga says this, or similar, in answer to any and every suggestion that he acted extraordinarily.

Did he ever consider fleeing entirely, to seek out a new life as a mercenary in Brahvniki or the like, or wish he had once he was in Arko? “No,” he answers. “I could never do that. The thought never came into my head. I will tell you this much, though: what Jinai meant by ‘pain huge beyond imagining,’ I didn’t really understand. It was indeed beyond what I could have imagined, then. And I’m glad I didn’t understand, because if I had, I’m not sure I wouldn’t have chickened out in one way or another. Life is merciful that way; it spares us foreknowledge.” Catching his own error, he adds with a rueful grin, “At least most of the time.”

Once he was on the road, was he afraid? “A little. But not for long, things happened so fast. We didn’t even get out of Roskat. Then… well, for the next two years, I kept thinking, ‘So this is how it plays out,’ at least in the times I was capable of thinking.”

Being betrayed by his Arkan escort, captured, raped, forced to fight in the Mezem, forced to kill his own people, drugged to betray Yeola-e’s military secrets, afflicted with the grium sefalian, bereaved of siblings and close friends both on the road and in Arko, and finally tortured so severely his mind was destroyed, albeit temporarily, all fell under that fleeting section of the reading, expressed by an augur’s few desperate words.

Chevenga did detail the reading to one person: his mother, whose own questionings by the Committee have revealed that she knew his personal secret from when he was eight. “She alone knew, so I always went to her when I was troubled with it, and I can’t say how much it helped, and how grateful I will always be. I really should not have gone to her with this. Call it a moment of weakness.

“She did not counsel me one way or another. She said that the one who knew best was me, and that I should trust myself, as she trusted me, entirely.”

Karani Aicheresa’s awareness of her son’s secret made her, in effect, an accessory to his violation of the Statute semanakraseyeni. He was worried she would be charged, but so far she has not. While many Yeolis argue vociferously that it was a travesty that he was charged, she is not likely to be.

The personal sacrifice he made included the possibility of being charged, which he also took on open-eyed, being well-versed in law. But did he think he would be?

“In truth, no,” he says. “Those who I told were very good about keeping it secret, and so it hadn’t come out. At twenty-eight-and-a-half, I didn’t think it would. So often life has plans for us that are different from our own. Once it was out, of course, I knew it might well happen.” Generous as ever, he once again has undertaken a personal sacrifice, with the intention of ending the trial at peace with even those who fear him most.

Chevenga’s decision to take things so much into his own hands that he didn’t even tell Assembly how imminent the Arkan invasion was is perhaps a precursor to the ruthless hard-mindedness he would show, when it was needed, while leading the army. “It’s as I said in the trial,” he says. “I—do you know what half-action is, what it means?

“It’s the course you take based on unclear thinking, based perhaps on a hope or a fear or perhaps a desperate wish. You think, ‘This must lead to things coming out right’ because you want it to, and you choose that way without playing out fully in your mind how things actually will come out if you do it. Because you aren’t sure, you don’t act with full conviction. And, like making half a leap across an abyss, it tends to lead to defeats.

“Revealing the reading to Assembly would have been half-action on my part. There were already good indications that the Arkans were coming, and we were already preparing, so warning would have made no difference in that way; nor did the reading give me the fact that they were planning the great diversion they did, else I’d have given warning for sure, stayed home, and set a trap of some kind so as to defeat them.

“If I’d have told Assembly, they’d have resolved to forbid me to go, because they would have considered it unconscionable to allow me to. Neither I nor you nor anyone could fault them for that. They would never have had the nerve, or, one might say, the cruelty, to send me into the eagle’s claws, or away from Yeola-e at all, when there was such a threat. It would have been understandable, but it would still have been half-action. And then the first or second forks would have played out. I couldn’t let that happen.”

Not even yet at his majority, Chevenga took all our fates into his own hands, without us knowing. To the Yeoli sensibility, it seems almost hubristic in a semanakraseye. In his questioning, Linasika pointed out that his judgment on one other major matter has been enormously in error. But one cannot argue with the ultimate results, the proof that our fates were in good hands. Jinai Oru’s augury played out mercilessly true, and Yeola-e is still free.



--

Read More......